We received a message from a couple, and judging from their photos they have above average good looks. But here's the twist: the women was listed in the profile as 5'8" and 110 pounds. Unfortunately, the women in the picture was probably 5'8", but her weight was closer to 140 pounds.
Mrs 2jersey is 5'3" and 120 pounds (on the button) - and she/we can easily tell the difference between a women who weighs 110 pounds and one who weighs considerably more. We're accepting of the fact that you can't always judge a person's age from their photos, some people age faster/slower than others. But a 30 pound weight difference on an average sized women is a large and obvious inaccuracy.
So, assuming the women in the photo is attractive, do you ding this couple based on this obvious/significant profile lie (dishonest people are unattractive)? Or do you ignore the lie and credit it to a women's right to not have to discuss her age or weight in public?