We finally did it!!! After only having threesomes in the past, hubby and I finally had our first foursome! We were with another couple this weekend, and while it was great, it ended strangely. Let me explain and perhaps I can get some feedback as to why this could've happened.
Hubby and I were at a party, drinking, laughing, having a good time. Towards the end of the night, there was another couple with whom we're friends (or rather, friendly aquaintances) but we don't hang out with them on a regular basis, nor do we live anywhere near them. The four of us proceeded to our home for an "afterparty" and neither of them know anything about our lifestyle. We had no intention of trying to seduce them, but merely enjoyed their company. We weren't drunk, but had had a few. We didn't drink once at home. Instead, the other woman suggested we play poker, which soon turned into strip poker. Things were fun and light and suddenly she mentioned she wanted to have an orgy. We just kind of laughed it off. She realized we have a jacuzzi tub and asked if we could all get in. Seeing as how we're naked anyways, I thought why not. Could be fun.
Well, it was fun. We were all laughing, having a good time, naked in the tub but nothing serious was happening. I thought it'd end there....but she kept mentioning she wanted an orgy and we kept laughing about it..not knowing if she was serious or not. Of course, the two of us girls ended up kissing on a dare I think...it just went from there. We all got out of the tub, hubby and I took a few moments to ourselves to discuss things and we were fine with how the evening was going. We thought giving them a few min would give them time to change their mind. They weren't ready to quit yet, though. WE all piled on the bed, and I asked them three times were they sure they wanted to continue. They assured us they did. SO......we did. It was fun!!!
Until.....Somewhere in the middle of things, somehow, things just seemed to get quiet and still. I don't know how to explain it, but it was just a feeling I got that something wasn't quite right. I asked them if everything was fine. Yes, they said. I asked the woman if she was okay. She said she was having fun. It went on for a few more min and then when we switched back to our own partners, they suddenly got up, got their clothes and went into the next room for bed. They didn't say anything to us then, and barely said goodbye in the morning.
Sorry this is so long, but I wanted to get everything out right. So.....needless to say, this left us both baffled. I thought we did everything right and I thought we'd made sure they were okay and comfortable the entire night. I don't know what went wrong...any ideas? I just emailed the other woman, but haven't heard back from her yet. I'm dying to know if it was something we did?! Do you guys see anything in that story that was a mistake that I'm just not seeing?
PS...if I can make things more clear by explaining something in more detail, please let me know